Only a few short months ago, Scottish FA chief football officer Craig Mulholland and chief executive Ian Maxwell touted their exhaustive global search for a new head coach. They introduced Sebastien Pocognoli at Hampden with significant fanfare, claiming the association had beaten several other clubs to secure his appointment. While the language used by officials at the time implied a major coup, the atmosphere surrounding the national team has soured dramatically, with the Tartan Army making their frustration known following Monday’s crushing 4-0 loss to Switzerland. The process all pointed to Sebastien Pocognoli being their guy. Told everybody that loads of clubs were on his tail but that they won the chase, they paraded him around Hampden. For coup, read boo, the sound surely reverberating around the Tartan Army right now after Monday’s 4-0 defeat by Switzerland.
Reports suggesting Pocognoli earns double the salary of his predecessor, Steve Clarke, have circulated, though the primary concern for the SFA is the lack of visible value on the pitch.
Clarke’s tenure, marked by three tournament qualifications, provided a substantial financial windfall for the association, enabling significant investment into grassroots initiatives. The prospect of missing out on major championships again remains a serious concern for the governing body, especially given that qualification for the next European Championship is considered highly accessible.
The current sense of drift within the squad is alarming and appears unsustainable. SFA leadership, including president Mike Mulraney, face growing pressure to justify the appointment. The reliance on data, analytics, and external metrics that initially backed the decision to hire Pocognoli now appears increasingly disconnected from the reality of the team’s on-field struggles. The data, the metrics, the cosmic input from the analytics company whose input was received at Hampden as if written on tablets of stone.





