Cricket Australia Rejects Probe into 2018 Ball-Tampering Scandal

Published: November 19, 2026, 9:17 am

Cricket Australia has officially ruled out re-opening an investigation into the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, confirming that the original inquiry is considered complete. Instead, the governing body plans to launch an independent forum as a “circuit breaker,” providing a space for players and staff to share their perspectives on the incident that occurred during the third Test in Cape Town eight years ago.

The move comes in the wake of renewed controversy sparked by Usman Khawaja’s recent autobiography. In his book, Khawaja claimed that the entire team was aware of the plot to alter the ball’s condition with sandpaper to generate swing—a claim that current captain Pat Cummins has strongly denied. A formal investigation conducted by Cricket Australia in 2018 resulted in bans and disgrace for Steve Smith, David Warner, and Cameron Bancroft, concluding that only those three individuals were involved.

David Warner, who supports Khawaja’s account, recently criticized the board, labeling the original inquiry a “shoddy investigation” and asserting that several players were never questioned. Chief executive Todd Greenberg acknowledged that the past week has been an “incredibly difficult and uncomfortable time for the game.” Despite the criticism, Greenberg insisted that the case is closed, citing confidentiality as the primary reason for refusing to make the findings public. However, speaking in Hobart ahead of Australia’s one-day clash with England on Wednesday, Greenberg was adamant that “the investigation has been completed” and ruled out making it public, citing confidentiality. According to khawaja, also on commentary for the match,, He welcomed a “safe space to chat”, but voiced concern that it would be behind closed doors.

“We’ve got almost everyone’s version of events, and they differ markedly,” Greenberg stated in Hobart. “Looking for the perfect truth doesn’t exist, and we’re not chasing that. We’re giving people the opportunity to have their version of events played into a safe place.” He clarified that the board is not attempting to appease any specific individual, but rather seeking to help the sport move forward after years of lingering resentment. “Australian cricket is at its strongest when we’re united, and we owe it to everyone who loves the game to make every reasonable effort to move forward together with understanding, respect and perspective.”. And are doing it again now, they caused enormous pain and hurt for lots of people.

Interim chairman David Boon confirmed that the proposed forum will likely be moderated by a former judge, though he stressed that no new sanctions would be imposed as a result of the sessions. “After careful discussion, we agreed to establish a forum that will allow players and staff involved in the events of South Africa in 2018 to share their experiences and their perspectives,” Boon explained. “We believe it is time for a circuit breaker.

This is not about litigating the past. It is about giving the opportunity to those involved to have their voices heard.”

While Cricket Australia hopes to conclude the project within a month, the organization has not committed to releasing the testimonies gathered. Greenberg noted that the board intends to be as transparent as possible while maintaining the confidentiality of participants. He also conceded that the organization shares responsibility for the environment at the time, acknowledging that the team culture was “quite toxic” and driven by a “win-at-all-costs mentality” that permeated the entire organization. According to greenberg, who took over at Cricket Australia in 2025,, The governing body also had to take some responsibility for the environment that existed in the team in 2018.

Public response from the players involved has been mixed. Warner reiterated his preference for an open inquiry over a closed-door forum, stating, “I would’ve liked an open inquiry, and the people that were there at the time actually can come forward and speak. It’s not about penalties. It’s about transparency and accountability.”

Khawaja similarly expressed reservations about the structure of the forum. “The biggest question I have is that the board makes the decisions of what comes out at the end,” he said. “How is that an actual way of trying to present what people have said? I can go in there and say something, but then the board can decide they’re not going to release that.”