Executive Complaints Unit (ECU) has officially upheld complaints regarding a derogatory remark made about Victoria Beckham during an episode of the satirical panel show Have I Got News For You. The broadcast, which aired on 7 November last year and was hosted by comedian Katherine Ryan, became the subject of viewer scrutiny after the presenter referenced an email allegedly written by Sir David Beckham that contained a strong expletive.
During the programme, Ryan addressed the panellists, stating, “I don’t know that we are allowed to broadcast the c-word, but you did reference Victoria Beckham earlier and we’ll allow that.” Two viewers subsequently filed formal complaints, arguing that the comment was gratuitously offensive. stated that there was no editorial justification for equating Victoria Beckham with such a deeply offensive term.
In its formal ruling, the ECU explained that while the inclusion of the slur itself was deemed editorially justified because the panel was analyzing a news story involving leaked emails from Sir David Beckham, the same could not be said for Ryan’s specific aside. The ECU noted, “In the ECU’s judgement, while the inclusion of the c-word in the programme derived editorial justification from David Beckham’s alleged use of it and the satirical reflections this prompted, there was no such justification for a comment which presented Victoria Beckham as equivalent to a particularly offensive word.”
The unit highlighted that while Editorial Guidelines do not mandate that programmes avoid causing offence entirely, they do require that any offence be editorially sound. The ECU had previously addressed concerns in November from viewers unhappy with the show’s use of strong language. At that time, the broadcaster maintained that the language was justified given the nature of the news story and noted that a verbal warning was provided at the start of the post-watershed broadcast.
“It is never our intention to offend our audience,” the statement added. Following the latest ruling, the findings have been reported to Content management. Consequently, the version of the programme currently available on iPlayer will be replaced by an edited version that removes the problematic exchange.
Comments